[Commlist] CFP Reexamining gender representations in film noir

Call for Paper – Special Issue #16

/Genre en séries : cinéma, télévision, medias/

https://journals.openedition.org/ges/ 
<https://journals.openedition.org/ges/>

*“Femmes fatales”, “Men in crisis”?*

*Reexamining gender representations in film noir*

**

Ever since their emergence in the field of academia, gender studies have 
looked closely at Hollywood film noir and neo-noir. Following the 
seminal book /Women in Film Noir/, edited by E. Ann Kaplan (1^rst ed. 
1978, 2^nd ed. 1998), important works have examined, using a 
psychoanalytic prism, the feminine (Doane 1991) and masculine (Krutnik 
1991) characters of this genre, before others used a variety of 
approaches more attentive to socio-historical factors. The gender issues 
of Hollywood film noir from the 1940s and 1950s were thus placed in a 
context marked by the upheavals of war and the post-war period, as well 
as by the development of consumer society and urban modernity (see, 
among others, Cohan 1997, Biesen 2005, Jankovich 2011), while their 
reinvestment by neo-noir from the 1980s onwards raised new questions 
about the ideological implications of such a generic recycling process, 
caught between the effects of sexual liberation and the persistence of a 
puritanical morality (Letort 2007). Whereas some chapters of /Women in 
Film Noir/ (Dyer 1998a and Kaplan 1998b) already pointed to the 
complexity and heterogeneity of gendered representations initially 
perceived as univocally misogynous, subsequent studies have further 
deconstructed this reductive vision (Cowie 1993, Spicer 2002, Hanson 
2007, Grossman 2009, etc.) by discussing the relevance and the limits of 
notions such as “femmes fatales” and “men in crisis” with regard to the 
variety of models of femininity and masculinity proposed by film noir 
(“girls next door”, “good-bad girl”, “weak guy”, “damaged man”, “tough 
guy”, etc.), from the classical period to the contemporary era.

Despite this long critical tradition, many aspects of film noir are yet 
to be analyzed from a gendered, and more broadly cultural, perspective, 
especially in the context of French film studies, where works on film 
noir that include this approach are still scarce (Letort 2010, Esquenazi 
2012, Pillard 2014 and 2019). This issue of /Genre en séries: cinéma, 
télévision, médias/ therefore proposes to revisit this genre 
historically central to feminist film studies, in order to contribute to 
the renewal and new directions of this teeming field of research. On the 
one hand, the aim will be to extend our knowledge of long neglected 
films in the noir corpus, such as the French “noir realism” (Burch and 
Sellier 1996) or German “Strassenfilm” (Wager 1999), and, on the other 
hand, to revisit (supposedly) already well-known films in order to 
deepen our understanding of them with the help of new methodological 
frameworks.

**

Among the productions that have remained largely ignored by works 
studying film noir through the prism of gender, we must first mention 
those belonging to non-Hollywood cinema. Since the turn of the 2000s, a 
certain number of works have contributed to reassesing the national 
boundaries of this cinematic genre hitherto perceived as fundamentally 
American, thus highlighting not only its European roots and the 
aesthetic and cultural transfers that run through it (Vincendeau 1992, 
Morgan and Andrew 1996), but also its “global” dimension (Desser 2003) 
and the different forms it takes outside of Hollywood. However, despite 
some noteworthy studies (Spicer 1999 and 2007, Hanson and O’Rawe 2010, 
Pillard 2014, Da Silva 2014, Walker-Morrison 2019), these phenomena of 
transnational circulation remain seldom explored through the prism of 
gender. Similarly, whereas the literature-cinema relationship remains 
inescapable when it comes to the noir genre as a whole (Tadié 2009), its 
transmediality is beginning to be considered along new lines, with 
research looking at radio, comics, and television (Schlotterbeck 2013, 
Lyons 2013, Sanders 2013). However, the gendered dimension of these 
productions is still rarely examined. Finally, as various articles on 
its classic Hollywood expression have already pointed out (Cook 1978, 
Cowie 1993, Martin 1998), the very definition of film noir is far from 
trivial with regards to the identities and gender relations it 
represents. It is therefore important to revisit the processes of 
perpetual redefinition of this protean corpus, both to question its 
boundaries, as works suggesting the existence of a “/noir women’s film/” 
or “/women’s film noir/” invite us to do (Walsh 1986, Esquenazi 2012), 
and to circumscribe its ideological stakes and tensions as finely as 
possible.

Moreover, hitherto under-exploited approaches could make it possible to 
renew research on film noir from a gender perspective. Reception studies 
are, for instance, rarely utilized beyond analysis of professional film 
reviews, even though they could shed light on the various uses and 
readings that ordinary spectators make of these films (Pillard 2015). An 
analysis of the promotional materials, especially those produced by the 
studios, would be likely to enrich this research by considering all the 
media texts available to the public, whose heterogeneity allows for a 
multitude of appropriations (Haralovich 2013). Similarly, the study of 
production archives would refine our understanding of the role played by 
specific producers, directors or screenwriters in the elaboration of the 
gendered representations conveyed by these films (Biesen 2005, Sonnet 
2011). For their part, star studies and acting studies would make it 
possible to analyze the way in which the persona of stars and their 
acting in films noirs participate in the construction of female and male 
models (or counter-models) specific to this genre (cf. Baron 2010). 
Finally, despite the existence of various works on racial issues 
(Diawara 1993, Lott 1997, Kaplan 1998c, Oliver and Trigo 2003), as well 
as representations of homosexuality and bisexuality (Dyer 1977, White 
1991, Dyer 1998b, Straayer 1998, Dyer 2002, etc.) in these productions, 
the often complex articulation of gender with class, race, ethnicity, 
sexuality, generation, etc., remains to be explored in many noir or 
neo-noir films.

Papers may focus on the following:

  * “Femmes fatales” and “men in crisis”: relevance and limits of these
    notions
  * Transnationalism / cultural transfers / remakes / intertextuality
  * Films noirs of lesser studied cinemas: Latin America, Europe, Asia, 
etc.
  * Socio-historical contextualization of classic and contemporary noir
  * Generic hybridity (noir and comedy/action/gothic female/SF/horror/etc.)
  * Production / promotional materials / receptions
  * Articulation of issues of gender, race, sexuality, class, etc.
  * Stars, acting, performance
  * Transmediality (cinema, literature, television, radio, comics, video
    games, etc.)
  * Definitions of the noir corpus: gender issues

*Submission guidelines:*

Submitted papers must not have been published in any other journal or 
conference proceedings.

The proposals will explain and justify precisely how they incorporate 
the existing literature on the genre and in relation to the notion of 
film noir.

Proposals (abstract of 500-800 words along with a short 
bio-bibliography) are to be sent to (thomas.pillard /at/ sorbonne-nouvelle.fr) 
<mailto:(thomas.pillard /at/ sorbonne-nouvelle.fr)> and (sandeau.jules /at/ gmail.com) 
<mailto:(sandeau.jules /at/ gmail.comb)>before *September 15, 2021*. A response 
will be given at the end of September, and the finished papers are to be 
submitted by March 15, 2022. They will then be subject to double-blind 
peer review. The issue will be published in fall 2022.

*Suggested references:*

Abbott, Megan E. (2002), /The Street Was Mine: White Masculinity in 
Hardboiled Fiction and Film Noir/, New York, Palgrave Macmillan.

Auerbach, Jonathan (2011), /Dark Borders: Film Noir and American 
Citizenship/, Durham & Londres, Duke University Press.

Baron, Cynthia (2010), “Film Noir: Gesture Under Pressure”, in Christine 
Cornea (ed.), /Genre and Performance: Film and Television/, Manchester, 
Manchester University Press, p. 18-37.

Biesen, Sheri Chinen (2005), /Blackout: World War II and the Origins of 
Film Noir/, Baltimore, Johns Hopkins University Press.

Boozer, Jack (1999), “The Lethal ‘Femme Fatale’ in the Noir Tradition”, 
/Journal of Film and Video/,//51(3-4), p. 20-35.

Britton, Andrew (1993), “Betrayed by Rita Hayworth: Misogyny in /The 
Lady from Shanghai/”, in Ian Cameron (ed.), /The Book of Film Noir/, New 
York, Continuum, p. 213-21.

Bronfen, Elisabeth (2004), “Femme Fatale: Negotiations of Tragic 
Desire”, /New Literary History/, 35(1), p. 103-116.

Bronfen, Elisabeth (2014), “Gender and Noir”, in Homer B. Pettey, R. 
Barton Palmer (eds.), /Film Noir/, Edinburgh, Edinburgh University 
Press, p. 143-163.

Burch, Noël & Sellier, Geneviève (1996), /La Drôle de guerre du cinéma 
français, 1930-1960/, Paris, Nathan.

Cohan, Steven (1997), /Masked Men: Masculinity and the Movies in the 
Fifties/, Bloomington & Indianapolis, Indiana University Press.

Cook, Pam (1978), “Duplicity in /Mildred Pierce/”, in E. Ann Kaplan 
(dir.), /Women in Film Noir/, Londres, British Film Institute, p. 69-80.

Cowie, Elizabeth (1993), “Film Noir and Women”, in Joan Copjec (ed.), 
/Shades of Noir:A Reader/, New York, Verso, p. 121-166.

Da Silva, Antônio Márcio (2014), /The “Femme” Fatale in Brazilian 
Cinema: Challenging Hollywood Norms/, New York, Palgrave Macmillan.

Desser, David (2003), “Global noir: Genre film in the age of 
transnationalism”, in Barry K. Grant (ed.), /Film Genre Reader III/, 
Austin, TX, University of Texas Press, p. 516-536.

Diawara, Manthia (1993), “Noir by Noirs: Towards a New Realism in Black 
Cinema”, /African American Review/, 50(4), p. 525-537.

Doane, Mary Ann (1991), /Femmes Fatales: Feminism, Film Theory, and 
Psychoanalysis/, New York, Routledge.

Dyer, Richard (1977), “Homosexuality and Film Noir”, /Jump Cut/ (16), 
p. 18-21.

Dyer, Richard (1998a), “Resistance Through Charisma: Rita Hayworth and 
/Gilda/”, in E. Ann Kaplan (ed.), /Women in Film Noir/, London, BFI, 
p. 115-122.

Dyer, Richard (1998b), “Postscript: Queers and Women in Film Noir”, in 
E. Ann Kaplan (ed.), /Women in Film Noir/, London, BFI, p. 123-129.

Dyer, Richard (2002), “Queer Noir”, in /The Culture of Queers/, London & 
New York, Routledge, p. 90-113.

Esquenazi, Jean-Pierre (2012), /Le Film noir. Histoire et significations 
d'un genre populaire subversif/, Paris, CNRS.

Farrimond, Katherine (2018), /The Contemporary Femme Fatale: Gender, 
Genre and American Cinema/, London & New York, Routledge.

Gates, Philippa (2014), “Independence Unpunished: The Female Detective 
in Classic Film Noir”, in Robert Miklitsch (ed.), /Kiss the Blood off My 
Hands: On Classic Film Noir/, Urbana, Univ. of Il. Press, p. 17-36.

Gopalan, Lalitha (2013), “Bombay Noir”, in Andrew Spicer and Helen 
Hanson (eds.), /A Companion to Film Noir/, Malden, MA, Wiley-Blackwell, 
p. 496-511.

Greven, David (2011), /Representations of Femininity in American Genre 
Cinema: The Woman’s Film, Film Noir, and Modern Horror/, New York, 
Palgrave MacMillan.

Grossman, Julie (2009), /Rethinking the Femme Fatale in Film Noir: Ready 
for Her Close-Up/, London, Palgrave Macmillan.

Grossman, Julie (2014), “Women and Film Noir: Pulp Fiction and the 
Woman’s Picture”, in Robert Miklitsch (ed.), /Kiss the Blood off My 
Hands: On Classic Film Noir/, Urbana, Univ. of Il. Press, p. 37-61.

Grossman, Julie (2020), /The Femme Fatale/, New Brunswick, Rutgers 
University Press.

Hanson, Helen (2007), /Hollywood Heroines: Women in Film Noir and the 
Female Gothic Film/, London, I. B. Tauris.

Hanson, Helen & Catherine O’Rawe (eds.) (2010), /The Femme Fatale: 
Images, Histories, Contexts/, Houndmills & New York, Palgrave Macmillan.

Forth, Christopher E. (2013), “‘Nobody Loves a Fat Man’: Masculinity and 
Food in Film Noir”, /Men and Masculinities/, 16(4), p. 387-406

Haralovich, Mary Beth (2013), “Selling Noir: Stars, Gender, and Genre in 
Film Noir Posters and Publicity”, in Andrew Spicer & Helen Hanson 
(eds.), /A Companion to Film Noir/, Malden, MA, Wiley-Blackwell, p. 245-263.

Harvey, Sylvia (1998), “Woman’s Place: The Absent Family of Film Noir.” 
in E. Ann Kaplan (ed.), /Women in Film Noir/, London, BFI, 1998, p. 22-34.

Hollinger, Karen (1996), “Film Noir, Voice-Over, and the Femme Fatale”, 
in Alain Silver & James Ursini (eds.), /Film Noir Reader/, New York, 
Limelight, p. 242-259.

Jamieson, Gill & Anne McVitie (2016), “Noir building? Understanding the 
Immersive Fandom of Noir City”, /Participations: Journal of Audience and 
Reception/, 13(1), p. 530-552.

Jancovich, Mark (2011), “‘Vicious Womanhood’: Genre, The Femme Fatale 
and Postwar America”, /Canadian Journal of Film Studies/, 20(1), p. 100-114

Kaplan, E. Ann (ed.) (1998a), /Women in Film Noir/, London, British Film 
Institute [1978].

Kaplan, E. Ann. (1998b), “The Place of Women in Fritz Lang’s /The Blue 
Gardenia/,” in E. Ann Kaplan (ed.), /Women in Film Noir/, London, BFI, 
p. 81-88.

Kaplan, E. Ann (1998c), “The ‘Dark Continent’ of Film Noir: Race, 
Displacement and Metaphor in Tourneur’s /Cat People/ (1942) and Welles’ 
/The Lady From Shanghai/ (1948)”, in E. Ann Kaplan (ed.), /Women in Film 
Noir/, London, BFI, p. 183-201

Krutnik, Frank (1991), /In a Lonely Street: Film Noir, Genre, 
Masculinity/, New York, Routledge.

Lee, Nikki J.Y & Julian Stringer (2013), “Film Noir in Asia: 
Historicizing South Korean Crime Thrillers”, in Andrew Spicer & Helen 
Hanson (eds.), /A Companion to Film Noir/, Malden, MA, Wiley-Blackwell, 
p. 477-495.

Letort, Delphine (2006), « Femme fatale/femme assassine dans le film 
noir : dévier le stéréotype », in Karine Hildenbrand (dir.), « Figures 
de femmes assassines – Représentations et idéologies », /CYCNOS/, 23(2), 
p. 147-159

Letort, Delphine (2010), /Du film noir au néo-noir : mythes et 
stéréotypes de l’Amérique, 1941-2008/, Paris, L’Harmattan.

Letort, Delphine & Gelly, Christophe (2017), “Women’s Song and Dance 
Performances in Film Noir”, in Alain Silver & James Ursini (eds.), /Film 
Noir: Light and Shadow/, New York, Applause Theatre & Cinema Book, 
p. 88-101.

Lott, Eric (1997), “The Whiteness of Film Noir”, /American Literary 
History/, 9(3), p. 542-566

Lyons, James (2013), “‘It Rhymes with Lust’: The Twisted History of Noir 
Comics”, in Andrew Spicer & Helen Hanson (eds.), /A Companion to Film 
Noir/, Malden, MA, Wiley-Blackwell, p. 458-475.

Martin, Angela (1998). “‘Gilda Didn’t Do Any of Those Things You’ve been 
Losing Sleep. Over!’: The Central Women of 40s Film Noir”, in E. Ann 
Kaplan (ed.), /Women in Film Noir/, London, BFI, p. 202-228.

Maury, Cristelle (2006), “Fighting One’s Way to Eroticism: the 
Representation of the Male Body in Postwar American Film Noir”, in 
Nieves Pascual, Laura Alonso-Gallo & Francisco Collado-Rodriguez (eds.), 
/Masculinities, Femininities and the Power of the Hybrid in US 
Narratives: Essays on ender Borders/, Heidelberg, Carl Winter Publishing 
House, p. 143-156.

Maury, Cristelle (2008), “‘The Dark Side of the Wartime Experience’? 
Calling into Question Feminist Film Noir Theory”, in Melvyn Stokes & 
Gilles Menegaldo (eds.), /Cinéma et histoire, Film and History/, Paris, 
Michel Houdiard, p. 89-103.

Maury, Cristelle (2011), « ‘Cops have homes too’ : les hommes ordinaires 
du film noir », in Noëlle de Chambrun (dir.), /Masculinité à Hollywood 
de Marlon Brando à Will Smith/, Paris, L’Harmattan, p. 119-142.

Maxfield, James F. (1996), /The Fatal Woman: Sources of Male Anxiety In 
American Film Noir, 1941-1991/, Madison, Fairleigh Dickinson University 
Press.

Morgan, Janice & Andrew, Dudley (1996), /Iris/ (21), « European 
Precursors of Film Noir/Précurseurs européens du film noir », p. 7-20.

Muller, Eddie (2001), /Dark City Dames: The Wicked Women of Film Noir/, 
New York, Regan Books.

Oliver, Kelly & Benigno Trigo (2003), /Noir Anxiety/, Minneapolis, 
University of Minnesota Press.

Pillard, Thomas (2014), /Le Film noir français face aux bouleversements 
de la France d'après-guerre (1946-1960)/, Nantes, Joseph K.

Pillard, Thomas (2015), « Le courrier des lecteurs du film complet : un 
outil pour évaluer les réceptions genrées des genres », in Gwénaëlle Le 
Gras et Geneviève Sellier (dir.), /Cinémas et cinéphilies populaires 
dans la France d’après-guerre, 1945-1958/, Paris, Nouveau Monde, p. 201-216

Pillard, Thomas (2019), /Le Quai des brumes de Marcel Carné/, Paris, 
Vendémiaire.

Roche, David & Maury, Cristelle (eds.) (2020), /Women Who Kill. Gender 
and Sexuality in Film and Series of the Post-Feminist Era/, London, 
Bloomsbury.

Sanders, Steven (2013), “Television Noir”, in Andrew Spicer and Helen 
Hanson (eds.), /A Companion to Film Noir/, Malden, MA, Wiley-Blackwell, 
p. 440-457.

Schlotterbeck, Jesse (2013), “Radio Noir in the USA”, in Andrew Spicer & 
Helen Hanson (eds.), /A Companion to Film Noir/, Malden, MA, 
Wiley-Blackwell, p. 423-439.

Sherwin, Miranda (2008), “Deconstructing the Male: Masochism, Female 
Spectatorship, and the Femme Fatale in /Fatal Attraction/, /Body of 
Evidence/, and /Basic Instinct/”, /Journal of Popular Film and 
Television/, 35(4), p. 174-182

Sonnet, Esther (2011), “Why Film Noir? Hollywood, Adaptation, and 
Women’s Writing in the 1940s and 1950s”, /Adaptation/, 4(1), p. 1-13

Spicer, Andrew (2014), /Film Noir/, London & New York, Routledge [2002].

Spicer, Andrew (ed.) (2007), /European Film Noir/, Manchester, 
Manchester University Press, 2007.

Spicer, Andrew (1999), “The Emergence of the British Tough Guy: Stanley 
Baker, Masculinity and the Crime Thriller”, in Steve Chibnall & Robert 
Murphy (eds.), /British Crime Cinema/, London & New York, Routledge, 
p. 81-93.

Straayer, Chris (1998), “Femme Fatale or Lesbian Femme: /Bound/ in 
Sexual /Différance/”, in E. Ann Kaplan (ed.), /Women in Film Noir/, 
London, BFI, p. 151-163.

Studlar, Gaylyn (2013), “The Corpse on Reprieve”: Film Noir’s Cautionary 
Tales of “Tough Guy” Masculinity”, in Andrew Spicer & Helen Hanson 
(eds.), /A Companion to Film Noir/, Malden, MA, Wiley-Blackwell, p. 369-386.

Tasker, Yvonne (2013), “Women in Film Noir”, in Andrew Spicer & Helen 
Hanson (eds.), /A Companion to Film Noir/, Malden, MA, Wiley-Blackwell, 
p. 353-368.

Vincendeau, Ginette (1992), « Noir is Also a French Word. The French 
Antecedents of Film Noir », in Ian Cameron (dir.), /The Movie Book of 
Film Noir/, Londres, Studio Vista, p. 49-58.

Wager, Jans B. (2005), /Dames in the Driver’s Seat: Rereading Film 
Noir/, Austin, University of Texas Press.

Wager, Jans B. (1999), /Dangerous Dames: Women and Representation in the 
Weimar Street Film and Film Noir/, Athens, Ohio University Press.

Walker-Morrison, Deborah (2019), /Classic French Noir: Gender and the 
Cinema of Fatal Desire/, London & New York, I.B.Tauris.

Walsh Andrea S. (1986), /Women’s Film and Female Experience. 1940-1950, 
/New York, Praeger.

White, Patricia (1991). “Female Spectator, Lesbian Specter: /The 
Haunting/”, in Diana Fuss (ed.), /Inside/Out: Lesbian Theories, Gay 
Theories/, New York, Routledge, p. 142-172.

---------------
The COMMLIST
---------------
This mailing list is a free service offered by Nico Carpentier. Please use it responsibly and wisely.
--
To subscribe or unsubscribe, please visit http://commlist.org/
--
Before sending a posting request, please always read the guidelines at http://commlist.org/
--
To contact the mailing list manager:
Email: (nico.carpentier /at/ vub.ac.be)
URL: http://nicocarpentier.net
---------------