[Commlist] CFP: How do we break something that is already broken? Virtual Assembly of the Critical AI Network

*How do we break something that is already broken? *
Virtual Assembly of the Critical AI Network, 27-29 May 2026
Centre for Philosophy and Critical Thought, Goldsmiths, University of 
London


Let us begin with our premise: AI is a broken technology. Despite the 
many hubristic claims made by its proprietary owners and amplified by 
the media, AI has no way to deliver on its promises to bring about 
societal benefits for all by increasing productivity, lowering costs, 
and accelerating innovation. Yet the rhetoric that surrounds AI’s 
incursions into our worlds of work and life has acted persuasively to 
cover for widespread precaritisation. Meanwhile, AI’s shoddy predictions 
and slop production further harm the marginalised and its immense 
resource demands hasten the destruction of the environment. Might we 
therefore not speculate that AI’s purpose is actually to break things by 
virtue of its very brokenness, not least any irksome movements towards 
racial, gender, class, or climate justice? 

AI may not be the cause of 
our current polycrisis but it condenses the forces that brought them 
about, which it then amplifies, intensifies, and adds to. A critical 
approach to AI rejects the inevitability of this state of affairs. 
Instead, a critical approach recognises AI as merely the latest broken 
product of an already broken system, peddled under a techno-utopian 
guise in a desperate attempt to persuade us that energy-guzzling machine 
gods are our only hope out of our predicament. We therefore posit that 
the entangled dynamics of AI are useful diagrams of the economic, 
political, and ideological syndromes that lie beneath. AI’s stuttering 
operations dredge up misshapen philosophies, colonial dreams and a 
reactionary contempt for relations of care, and put them on full 
display. Our approach to AI asks how we break this brokenness. How can 
we who are forced to inhabit the dysfunction that AI names resist AI, 
recompose liveable lives from within the wreckage of computational 
nihilism, and craft its distortions into infrastructures for the common 
good?

*Open Call for Participants: Critical AI Virtual Assembly*
This assembly is an initiative of the Critical AI Network and our email 
list will be the main communication channel for it. If you are 
interested in taking part, either as a contributor or a participant, 
please sign up to the list here: 
https://jiscmail.ac.uk/CPCT-CRITICALAINETWORK 
<https://jiscmail.ac.uk/CPCT-CRITICALAINETWORK>.

The virtual assembly 
will take place online on 27, 28 and 29 May 2026 from4-8pm (UK). For 
this inaugural event, we have identified three domains of inquiry to 
explore as a first step: 


A. AI in Education, AI as Education — Wednesday, 27 May 2026
How has AI been insinuated into education, and in what ways has AI been 
taken for education itself, overtaking, eliminating, or usurping the 
civic and/or intellectual purposes of formal and informal learning? What 
are some of your case studies of local policy and examples of lived 
experience we might learn from? How might we formulate the most 
effective counterarguments - and organizing - against the integration of 
AI into our curricula and delivery that address local policy and 
financial conditions? 


B. AI in and as Law, Governance, and Politics — Thursday, 28 May 2026
As AI creeps into normalised deployment in legal practice, policy 
articulation, and decision making in the guise of efficiency and 
accuracy, questions have yet to be posed about the impact on labour 
conditions and labour law, the status of evidence, the right to refuse, 
and the rights of those affected by AI-facilitated decisions, to name 
just a few. Moreover, the extent to which AI is being used to manipulate 
democratic elections via data harvesting, psychographic profiling, and 
micro-targeting, amongst other strategies, has raised seemingly 
unanswerable questions about the future of democracy. Indeed, is 
politics even possible in the age of AI? How might we set about 
articulating and answering some of these questions? How might we 
question the role of governance, whether of the state or of the 
institution, in mediating and facilitating the introduction of AI into 
all facets of our lives? 


C. The Ecology of AI, AI and the Environment — Friday, 29 May 2026
Guided by the premise that under the hood, AI is simply the same 
technology whether it is being introduced into education or other 
domains of life, we ask how we might articulate and analyze the 
relations forged by AI between vastly different areas that hitherto 
appeared to be unconnected. What insights might be gained from situating 
AI within an ecology? How does AI compete with others in this ecology 
for natural resources, and what can be done to mitigate, contain, or 
reverse this impact? If, as we propose, AI should be evaluated not as a 
tool with a use value but rather as the latest symptom of misused 
infrastructures, how might we articulate the counterproductivity that AI 
adoption represents within its ecology for any green policy?

Our hope is to collect and publish a record of our discussions in a new 
blog we will be setting up for the network.

_How do I participate?_
Our working premise is that by virtue of having our data mined and 
colluding with the training of models with or without remuneration or 
consent, **we are all data workers in the age of AI**. Anyone who is a 
data worker in this sense is invited to participate. 

There are three ways in to be a part of this assembly:
(i) We invite you to contribute short (10 minute) position 
papers falling within one of the domains above. We welcome and value 
'non-academic' contributions such as local case studies, reflections on 
personal experience, reports from activists, amongst others. We 
especially encourage submissions from underrepresented voices. In order 
to maximize accessibility, papers will be precirculated and panel 
speakers will present them briefly, followed by discussion. Papers have 
the option of being published on our blog.
(ii) We invite non-presenting attendees to consider participating as 
a note-taker at one of the sessions, with your notes published 
afterwards in a distilled and narrative form on our blog.
(iii) We invite you to attend any number of our panels as a discussant.

If you would like to be a part of the assembly, please fill out the form 
at _https://forms.gle/McxCu65qz2ymBepS8 to send us:
1 Your preferred mode of participation ((i) presenter; (ii) note-taker; 
(iii) discussant).
2 If you selected (i) or (ii), please indicate which domain (A. AI in 
Education, AI as Education (27 May 2026); B. AI in and as Law, 
Governance, and Politics (28 May 2026); C. The Ecology of AI, AI and the 
Environment (29 May 2026)) you would like to either present or take 
notes in.
3 If you selected (i), please include a max. 250w abstract of the paper 
you would like to present.
4 Finally, for all participants, please include a brief 100w bio that 
includes your (academic or non-academic) institutional affiliation and 
position (e.g., student, professor, IT worker, curator, etc.).

*The submission deadline is Friday, 20 March 2026 at 11:59pm. *

_How do I join the Critical AI network?_
If you have received this CFP and are not already a member of our 
network, but would like to join and participate in the assembly, please 
subscribe to our mailing list at 
https://jiscmail.ac.uk/CPCT-CRITICALAINETWORK 
<https://jiscmail.ac.uk/CPCT-CRITICALAINETWORK>.

_Who do I contact if I have questions?_
If you have questions, feel free to get in touch with the organisers:
Dan McQuillan (Computing) d.mcquillan [at] gold.ac.uk <http://gold.ac.uk>

Julia Ng (Literary Studies) j.ng [at] gold.ac.uk <http://gold.ac.uk>

Andres Saenz de Sicilia (Sociology) a.saenzdesicilia [at] gold.ac.uk 
<http://gold.ac.uk> 

Deirdre Daly (CALL) d.daly [at] gold.ac.uk <http://gold.ac.uk>

Jenny Doussan (Visual Cultures) d.doussan [at] gold.ac.uk 
<http://gold.ac.uk>

---------------
The COMMLIST
---------------
This mailing list is a free service offered by Nico Carpentier. Please use it responsibly and wisely. The commlist has no responsibility for any damage caused by its postings. Subscription to the list automatically implies agreement with this rule.
--
To subscribe or unsubscribe, please visit http://commlist.org/
--
Before sending a posting request, please always read the guidelines at http://commlist.org/
--
To contact the mailing list manager:
Email: (nico.carpentier /at/ commlist.org)
URL: http://nicocarpentier.net
---------------